Bertoglio's Pizza

Seven Bertoglio shows off a pizza before it is delivered to a customer Friday afternoon in Yelm.

former Eatonville-based pizza establishment is now looking to establish roots and grow in Yelm. 

Bertoglio’s Pizza recently finished up a move to Yelm and had a soft opening last week at their new location at 704 W. Yelm Ave. in the building where Nisqually Valley Brewing Company was previously located.

Bertoglio's Pizza

Bertoglio's Pizza is located at 704 W. Yelm Ave.

Owner Seven Bertoglio said he’s been getting a lot of support since he began leasing the building in May in preparation for the recent opening. 

“It has been great. From the chamber of commerce to the city, to the local businesses and the different restaurants that I’ve been going to — I’ve gotten a lot of good support, a lot of good suggestions. Everyone’s been very helpful,” said Bertoglio, who originally opened his namesake pizzeria nearly seven years ago. 

Bertoglio's Pizza

A pizza is seen on display before being delivered to a customer Friday afternoon at Bertoglio's Pizza in Yelm.

From meatball melts to handcrafted special pizzas, Bertoglio’s serves a little something for everybody, including a selection of beer and wine. The business also serves a lunch special, which includes a two-topping flatbread pizza with fountain drink for $6.99. 

There are also vegan pizza options with a red or barbecue sauce base, and Bertoglio’s can make almost any pizza gluten free, the restaurant owner said. 

Bertoglio's Pizza

Bertoglio's Pizza is located at 704 W. Yelm Ave.

But what really sets Bertoglio’s apart from the competition is its toppings — fresh and lots of them. 

“Build ‘em like you want to eat ‘em,” Bertoglio said. “Everything’s always fresh.” 

Bertoglio's Pizza

A pizza is seen on display before being baked Friday afternoon at Bertoglio's Pizza in Yelm.

Bertoglio said the move to Yelm was sparked by a need to expand. After a fairly extensive search in Eatonville, Bertoglio started broadening his search outside of the small Pierce County town. New pizza places were also opening up too, which stiffened competition in the community of more than 3,000 people. 

Bertoglio said when he saw the retail location on Yelm Avenue, which was originally built in 1933 and includes 1,900 square feet of woodsy interior, he knew it was the perfect fit for a pizza place. Plus, it was a major upgrade from the 600-square-foot location in Eatonville, which was purely takeout. 

“It’s so cool, the facade. It just looks like it should be a pizza place, to me,” Bertoglio said. “I just kept my eye on it, and when it became available after Nisqually Brewing moved out, I moved in right away.” 

Bertoglio's Pizza

Employees Destiny Beckman, left, and Kim Waldrop, right, prepare pizza and breadsticks Friday afternoon at Bertoglio's Pizza in Yelm.

Besides the favorable location with easy access to Yelm’s downtown corridor, Bertoglio said it was also important that they have a commercial kitchen and bar already installed. 

“The price to install a commercial kitchen was just astronomical for me. I needed a place that had been a restaurant before that had at least the basics for me to start with, instead of remodeling completely,” he said. “I mean, it took me five months (to open) and this place already has a kitchen and a bar. So I can just imagine what it would have taken me to start from scratch.” 

Bertoglio's Pizza

The bar area is seen Friday afternoon at Bertoglio's Pizza in Yelm.

And nearly five months later, Bertoglio’s Pizza opened Thursday, Sept. 19, with a soft opening. Bertoglio said he is currently in the process of scheduling a ribbon-cutting ceremony with the Yelm Area Chamber of Commerce. 

And while Bertoglio said he and his business are going to miss the clientele that kept them chugging along for so many years, he’s hoping the Yelm community will embrace the business with just as much love. 

Bertoglio's Pizza

From left to right, Kendall Sweet, Ann Grace, Jason Nimocks, and Destiny Beckman partake in job duities Friday afternoon at Bertoglio's Pizza in Yelm.

Bertoglio said the new restaurant isn’t currently hiring, but they might bring on a couple new faces from the community in the near future. There are currently seven employees on staff. 

For more information on the restaurant and to view its menu, visit Bertoglio’s Pizza on Facebook. 

Bertoglio's Pizza

Seven Bertoglio, left, and Kelly May, right, talk about their craft in the kitchen Friday afternoon at Bertoglio's Pizza in Yelm.

Recommended for you

(0) comments

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.